Your Deathly Hallows reactions
Your Deathly Hallows reactions Post your thoughts on Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows in the comments of this post, so we can try to keep the discussion more relevant in other news posts!

Go - spill!
Posted by Emerson on Jul 23rd | 10625 Comments
Visitor Comments
Posted by ginerva_weasley Jul 23rd 2007

best book yet! but we didnt find out half of what Jo told us we would! Was I the only one who found the epilouge cheesy? Otherwise, best book yet.


Posted by Stuart3333 Jul 23rd 2007

OK it was way good but did any one else realize that freakin Mrs Weasley killed somoene wow i love how she was like girl but also we never found out wat was behind the veil and also wat was the point of having bill get bitten like they mentioned 1 difference he like to eat his meat raw but that was it it was a little annoying


Posted by jaymedavanzo Jul 23rd 2007

Absolutely loved it, especially Kreature leading the Hogwarts house elves into the battle! All of the deaths were so sad... especially Snape (after seeing all of the memories he gave Harry). Thought the trio living in a tent got boring, and the epilogue was a bit 'blah' but in all, an excellent way to end the series. It's so sad to know we'll never have another one to look forward to...


Posted by Gemini531 Jul 23rd 2007

Absolutely loved it. Yeah, I have a question or two, but the woman couldn't anticipate everything, so I think people need to give her a break - she truly worked hard on this entire series and I don't have a single complaint (except that the epilogue was a tad bit cheesy). JKR is an awesome author and I couldn't be happier with the book!!


Posted by markevans Jul 23rd 2007

wow in the two seconds it took for me to click to make a comment, it went from no coments to over ten omments...lol so anyway. i thought this was a rather good book. although it seemed GREATLY reminiscent of a fanfiction, i don't know why, there were just so many things...like the sword im the lake and the idea of the flesh mark or whatever on the snitch, when it's never been mentioned before, not even in Quidditch Through The Ages...but it was never-the-less a very good book. i think that Lupin and Tonks were the two that died that weren't supposed to because they seemed so thrown in. Harry was the one who got the repreive, obviously, he literally died then came back. i wasn't so happy with the epilogue, it was a little too happy and perfect, ya know? i loved that mrs. weasley killed bellatrix, especially with her, um 'choice words' lol. i thought for sure hermione was sa goner in the malfoy manor chapter. i also found it hilarious that even though ron has managed to actually say a few romantic sounding things to her, she doesn't kiss him until he mentions evacuating house elves. like she's turned on by house elf safety or something lol.


Posted by xenophiliusx Jul 23rd 2007

I think that the eqilouge was a little open ended about what had happened to most of the other characters was because jkrowling is going to write more books...well hopefully....


Posted by jacbarefoot Jul 23rd 2007

one word: disappointed


Posted by kiona76 Jul 23rd 2007

It was diffinitely a good book. it's now my 2nd favorite book. however, i really was disappointed in the epilogue too. It didn't really tell us much. I'm glad that Harry and Ginny were together same with Ron and Hermione, but what about everyone else? I was also really upset with Lupin and Tonks. Why did both of them have to die? The book was great, but i was alittle disappointed at the end. I was determined to see Harry die....not that i wanted him too, but i was certain that he would die and give everyone this special ending about heroes or something. Oh well, great book! ^^


Posted by GlobalGirlK Jul 23rd 2007

I liked it although I am very sad at Sev's death. He was one of my favorite characters and I'll miss him. *sniffles* I'm glad that many of the characters were redeemed and wish that the epilogue had been a bit more detailed. It was good and I'm glad that I was there for the end.


Posted by Scorpius Jul 23rd 2007

By far my favorite in the series. I absolutely loved it and I thought the epilogue was perfect as well. I couldn't be happier with the end of the series.


Posted by maraisgod Jul 23rd 2007

AAAAAAAAAAWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW WWWWWSOME!!!!!!! I Love the book one moment i'm laughing then i'm crying my eyes out..... i'm still crying over Dobby and Snape they had it hard and died for the people they loved and that in any situations sucks


Posted by Love_Of_Emerson Jul 23rd 2007

One thing I don't understand is how Dumbledore didn't seem to really care about Harry...or did I read that wrong? It looked like Snape cared more about Harry's safety than Dumbledore had.


Posted by CMcG07 Jul 23rd 2007

woah, it was flippin amazing!!!!!!!!!! so intense and dark. but i loved it that way! i think i cried about 10 different times. neville rocked!!!! i love snape! soo many good things in this book. kept me on the edge of my seat every chapter, i never got bored. and the thing i loved most about it was that it was just SO different from the others in the series. jkr really rocked this one!!


Posted by mischiefmanaged128 Jul 23rd 2007

The book was amazing, much more dark and "adult." The Battle at Hogwarts was AMAZING, as was most of the book. However, sucked; it was like poorly-written Fan Fiction. Who was the person who showed magic later in life? I feel there were so many things she promised she'd answer and didn't.


Posted by iamhouseelf Jul 23rd 2007

i loved it i absolutly loved it there were times when i cried so hard i had to stop reading but i loved it, maybe there'll be a more complete epilouge, if she writes an encyclopedia?? i don't like the 19 year gap, but all in all, no one will ever write a better series in my opinion, it was funny too, u know when people weren't dieing, AWESOME -DOBBY STILL RULES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!


Posted by acciostiney Jul 23rd 2007

It's funny, I remember being dead-set AGAINST the whole, harry is a horcrux thing. But now that I've read how it was written and put in there, I love it. I thought the overall thing was great. it was most defindently the best one by far. The epilougue was different then I thought it would be. I hadn't expected it to be quite so fluffy, but i'm a softy for Happy endings. So, I loved it. Overall. It was absoultely AMAZING!


Posted by ambrlor Jul 23rd 2007

Mixed feelings . . . I think it would have been better received had she not promised answers to so many things that she then left out of the book. And the writing was inconsistent; she went back and forth between the childish tone of the first few books and the darker, more complex tone of the later books. It read like fanfic to me, but a really good fanfic. I like where she went with it, but it definitely wasn't my favorite of the series like I expected it to be. I didn't mind the epilogue as much as some, but I felt that the book as a whole made a lackluster ending. But do I regret buying it? Not a chance!


Posted by Hpfanaticgrl Jul 23rd 2007

JKR wrote a fantastic ending to this wonderful series. She couldn't have done it better. The writing was great, and it made you realize that this is NOT just a Children's book, but really an adult book. I really really enjoyed this book. There were some tears, I admit, but I really really was happy with the way it turned out. Fantastic!


Posted by hannahrd Jul 23rd 2007

I thought it was a fantastic end to an amazing series. I enjoyed finding out whether all my predictions had been right or wrong. I thought the epilogue was okay but I would really like to know more, like what everyone did for a living, and perhaps how the new ministry was treating muggleborns, goblins, and elves.


Posted by keonemalie Jul 23rd 2007

Wow, top 25? That's a first. Anyway, I think this is the best book in the series, probably my favorite book of the year. It was so much more mature, and, being 18 and having read the books for at least 8 years, I love the fact that I've grown up with the Trio and was part of the HP experience. I was terrified opening the book, afraid of what would happen, and upon closing it, I cried and cried and I still can't really believe it's done. CNN calls the time after 7/21 AH: the After-Harry era! As I keep thinking back on the book, important details just pop out (Snape's last words, Dumbledore's portrait) and really make me realize how deep these words, albeit fiction, can touch millions of people. I know one day, my children will read these books, and although they might not fully understand it, I'm sure they'll enjoy it, because, let's face it: These books are relatable, timeless, immortal.


Posted by HilaryW Jul 23rd 2007

I thought it was fantastic. I loved the non-stop action. And Kreacher leading the house elves into battle. I'm glad that Neville finally made his grandmother proud, he's such an incredible character. And Mrs. Weasley taking on Bellatrix Lestrange? Best duel bar none.


Posted by violetmarie17 Jul 23rd 2007

i wanted teddy to live with Harry. wait i dont remember reading about victoire at all? i need to go back now!!! TED TONKS was the one to do magic late in life. he was a muggle remember? then he told harry he had healed his leg, foot, arm--whatever.


Posted by loved_devil Jul 23rd 2007

What an amazing book! I couldn't put it down. It was so different from all the other books, which was annoying me in the begining, but i got over that quickly. I really thought that the epilouge was a waste, it wasn't nessacary at all. It was an all around amazing book, and it's sooo heartbreaking thats it over. Although I think that anyone could continue the story (including JKR) because the main charcters are all still alive. Maybe JKR doesn't WANT to write moe books, but the option is defiantly open for other authors.


Posted by savahnabanana Jul 23rd 2007

It is AH-MAZING! My favorite book! Though i am mourning the deaths I am very ecstatic about the ending! The Epilouge was a bit odd but all in all i LURVED it!


Posted by fatso Jul 23rd 2007

Brilliant! My favourite book...but the epilogue was abit dissapointing....


Posted by mjohn53 Jul 23rd 2007

I'm honestly a little disappointed. There were far too many unanswered questions. It makes me feel a little like there were plot points left open in previous books which Rowling had no intention of closing up--just to generate speculation and to sell books. I feel a little taken advantage of!


Posted by xopinkribbon Jul 23rd 2007

All around, I truly enjoyed it. Jo did it very well, as we all expected she would. Certain things were disappointing, such as the unanswered questions and holes left unfilled that other people have mentioned. Also, out of all people who could have died, WHY Fred, seriously!? Extremely depressing, same thing with Dobby. Oh, and although I did expect more information from the epilogue, I actually now think it was the only way the book really could have been ended...really nice.


Posted by bridgetmalfoy Jul 23rd 2007

I thought the book was fabulous, probably my favorite by far. It's true that we didn't find out about a a lot of stuff, but i believe Jo had her reasons for not giving us information about everything. I absolutely loved the ending sequence when Harry and Voldemort were dueling, probably my favorite scene out of all seven books combined. I still am not quite sure what to think about epilouge, but i think the ending was very satisfying. I am not quite that shocked that all three of mugglenet's theories were proven right. They are the biggest fan site in the WORLD! :D


Posted by ggKimmieGal Jul 23rd 2007

It was the most amazing story I have ever read in my entire life. I have never read a book that evoked so many emotions from me before. I cried through the last 100 pages. And the epilogue was so sweet and perfect, it made me cry some more. For those of you confused, Ron was the one who did magic late in life. He was able to speak parseltongue late in life. That's a really rare ability that wizards thought you had to be born with.


Posted by hermione214 Jul 23rd 2007

OMG!!! that book was so awesome!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!! yet so sad :( i cried so hard throughout the book, and was bawling when i was finished. it was so good that it made me feel like i was watching a movie instead of reading a book. what really got me was fred dying. you know george would never be right after that :( but i still LOVED it!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Posted by psychobabe Jul 23rd 2007

I really enjoyed it. Most of it was expected, I guess. I loved when Molly Weasley killed Bellatrix and I was so sad about Dobby's and Snape's death. I know... the rest of the deaths were sad too. Althought the Epilogue didn't nothing that really interested me... I still don't understand what happens with the veil in the ministry. ¿?


Posted by Spade583 Jul 23rd 2007

Zomagosh there was so much death. Fred! Anyone but Fred! and DOBBY! I enjoyed learning about Dumbledore's past and when I read him and Grindelwald were buddies I thought i'd read it wrong. I loved Luna and I also loved Hermione and Ron finally having that kiss ;) although Ron annoyed me a bit in the middle when he went off on one. He redeemed himself tho. Xenophilius Lovegood! I wish i lived with the Lovegoods. I loved the child being called Albus Severus in the epilogue. Good old Snapey. Oh and did we find out what Dudley saw when he faced the dementor? Coze i didnt spot it.


Posted by alexandrariddle Jul 23rd 2007

Not my favorite book. It comes in second place, but it was awesome. ALso, very cool to see some of my predictions come true.


Posted by dude098 Jul 23rd 2007

Best book of the series, but the epilogue was really bad. It didn't say anything new. I was hoping for a little more details about more of the characters and about Hogwarts. The book was brilliant though, she should have just added more to the epilogie.


Posted by dude098 Jul 23rd 2007

Best book of the series, but the epilogue was really bad. It didn't say anything new. I was hoping for a little more details about more of the characters and about Hogwarts. The book was brilliant though, she should have just added more to the epilogue.


Posted by MsGranger Jul 23rd 2007

polkadotted --- i agree with you, i didnt liek the epilogue i wanted it to be abit more longer. and true there weren't alot of questions answered. Overall i absolutly love the book. My order 1.7th, 2. 5th, 6th, 4th (i cant choose??) 3. 3rd 4. 1st 5. 2nd


Posted by surabura517 Jul 23rd 2007

loved it... stayed up for 12 hours straight til i finished it. best of the series. i definitely have some questions left, but without a doubt amazing!!! i just wish my friends would read faster so i have someone to discuss it with!!


Posted by Fukuro Jul 23rd 2007

It was Awesome but it does make me kind of sad that it's the last one I found out a lot of things but I still got some questions that I would liked answered but Overall it was a really great written book.


Posted by cantwait4book7 Jul 23rd 2007

One word: wow. It was such a great book. Perfect way to end the series, although I do agree there were some gaping plot holes. And the poor people who died! RIP Hedwig/Dobby/Fred/Lupin/T onks. Those hit me hard. The epilogue left so much unanswered! Oh and quick question: Are Voldemort and Harry related?! Cuz if Voldemort is a descendant of the Gaunts, who claim to be descended from the Peverells, and Harry is a descendant of the last of the Three Brothers (Ignotus Peverell), then that means they are distantly related!


Posted by the_other_hermynginny Jul 23rd 2007

WOW!!! I think my friends hated me because first i'm a really fast reader so i finished before everyone...and i was always ahead of them in the book so like they would be reading one thing where there is little action and i would be like " OMGOSH!!!! " sort of thing. I was number 10 at the book store so i grabbed my copies ( 3 for my friends 1 for me so we wouldn't have to wait forever!!! ) and like ran out of there to avoid spoilers and people were staring at me but some we're clapping... it was really fun!!!! I loved the book... i rank them 7,5,4,6,3,1,2... I 'm rereading it now though... I was sad that some characters died... DOBBY!!!!!! but other then that i understand why those characters had to die. Unlike most people i really liked the epilogue. It told you just enough to solve the big mysteries but it left you to imagine what everyone else ends up doing. Which personally i thought was great!!! I'm sure JKR will answer more questions on her website and what not... so yup those are my thoughts in a nutshell!!!! ! still a potter fan !


Posted by tribute_to_Dobby Jul 23rd 2007

AMAZING!!!! Dobby and Snape :(. But ending was a bit vague. Hogwarts scene was so cool!!! Wish it could have lasted longer, especially when the house elves join in


Posted by padfootisnotdead Jul 23rd 2007

okay, so it could have been better- but was ok. It was def by far not the best of jk's writing. It really did seem rushed. It seemed to start out very intense from the beginning, but the intensity never loosened up. The period when Ron left seemed very tedious and almost made me want to stop reading. Also, a lot of the hallows/ horcruxes stuff was confusing. Still, a lot of questions are unanswered. ex: why did the weasley's have 7 kids and what was Ginny's significance. I was really hoping for some kind "why "#7" " explanation. "7" has been used for everything- from school years, to kids, to possible horcruxes (even though there were 8), etc. I also wished Ginny could have been with them (the trio) more. For a lot of the book, it was just the trio- so I wished it had included a lot of the characters throughout the book besides just the battle scene. (which I thought was great). I only cried a little when Dobby died and when Harry knew he had to "die". Other than that, I think there was SOO much death, it just wasn't sad anymore. I cried when Cedric, Sirius (we didn't get a good explanation of that at all :( ), and when Dumbledore died. But I just didn't get the same effect with DH. At first the I thought epilogue was ok, but then I realized that she left a LOT of the characters out. What did/do they do with the rest of their lives..? ***What do you guys think about HARRY being the one to do magic in "later" life??*** So far no one has come up with this. Since he technically did do magic in "later" life. JK never specified that it had to be a squib, so what do you think.*** I really hope JK answers our questions soon either with a charity book or on her website- because there is still SO much left open and unended.....


Posted by prkosmos Jul 23rd 2007

what was the deal with Lupin in this book? he seemed really different in some parts like with him and harry,it just made me wonder what the point was in that....


Posted by Kaleygurl Jul 23rd 2007

I loved the book! The epilogue wasn't my favorite, I found it VERY vague. I wanted to hear more about people. Where was Luna? What were everyone's occupations? What else happened to Neville besides being the Herbology teacher?


Posted by fredRIP Jul 23rd 2007

oh man its over! =[ i am so sad that i cant ever go on a new adventure with harry and the trio again.... i loved the book until the epiloge then i got all sad and depressed by far my favorite part was mrs.weasley's "NOT MY DAUGHTER YOU girl!"


Posted by dumbledoreswoolnsox_22 Jul 23rd 2007

I really loved it! It was so sad though! All of the deaths and injuries- I cried so much! The epilogue was a nice ending to it. Getting to see what their kid's names were, and seeing Draco and his son. It was awesome Harry got to see Dumbledore and Neville was a real hero!!! I thought the epilogue was actually good. She let out enough information to let us know everything was good, but there is still a mystery to it. It was just wonderful!!!!!! There is one thing that confused me (and a lot have already pointed it out too) Who did magic later in life?


Posted by NOFX4343 Jul 23rd 2007

amazing battle, amazing book, crappy epilogue. best book ever


Posted by HPKiwi Jul 23rd 2007

i thought this was an amazing book. even though some of the theories and rumors running around were true (ex. snape loving lily and such) you still had NO idea it was coming, and when it did it was still amazing how she brought it all together. i had trouble with the epilogue - i agree, it's hard to put boy harry in an old person's body, and i would have rather heard about him and ginny just getting married, and ron and hermione, and what happened to everyone. i could have enjoyed just a list of what happened to every character. but i think if i read it enough, and if it satisfied jo, then i'm happy. a couple little questions or little details remain unknown that i'm sure she'd answer if they were overlooked or something. i really really hope she eventually makes an option for questions that she can answer! keep in touch, jo! congratulations, you did it!!! -Kirsten


Posted by briannapotter Jul 23rd 2007

in five words: perfect, love, beautiful, emotional and everlasting.


Posted by iMetRupertGrint Jul 23rd 2007

WHY WAS THE BOOK ONLY 759 PAGES I THOUGHT IT WAS SUPPOSED TO BE 784 I WANT THOSE 25 PAGES!!!!!


< 1 - 50 51 - 100 101 - 150 151 - 200 201 - 250 251 - 300 301 - 350 351 - 400 401 - 450 451 - 500 501 - 550 551 - 600 601 - 650 651 - 700 701 - 750 751 - 800 801 - 850 851 - 900 901 - 950 951 - 1000 1001 - 1050 1051 - 1100 1101 - 1150 1151 - 1200 1201 - 1250 1251 - 1300 1301 - 1350 1351 - 1400 1401 - 1450 1451 - 1500 1501 - 1550 1551 - 1600 1601 - 1650 1651 - 1700 1701 - 1750 1751 - 1800 1801 - 1850 1851 - 1900 1901 - 1950 1951 - 2000 2001 - 2050 2051 - 2100 2101 - 2150 2151 - 2200 2201 - 2250 2251 - 2300 2301 - 2350 2351 - 2400 2401 - 2450 2451 - 2500 2501 - 2550 2551 - 2600 2601 - 2650 2651 - 2700 2701 - 2750 2751 - 2800 2801 - 2850 2851 - 2900 2901 - 2950 2951 - 3000 3001 - 3050 3051 - 3100 3101 - 3150 3151 - 3200 3201 - 3250 3251 - 3300 3301 - 3350 3351 - 3400 3401 - 3450 3451 - 3500 3501 - 3550 3551 - 3600 3601 - 3650 3651 - 3700 3701 - 3750 3751 - 3800 3801 - 3850 3851 - 3900 3901 - 3950 3951 - 4000 4001 - 4050 4051 - 4100 4101 - 4150 4151 - 4200 4201 - 4250 4251 - 4300 4301 - 4350 4351 - 4400 4401 - 4450 4451 - 4500 4501 - 4550 4551 - 4600 4601 - 4650 4651 - 4700 4701 - 4750 4751 - 4800 4801 - 4850 4851 - 4900 4901 - 4950 4951 - 5000 5001 - 5050 5051 - 5100 5101 - 5150 5151 - 5200 5201 - 5250 5251 - 5300 5301 - 5350 5351 - 5400 5401 - 5450 5451 - 5500 5501 - 5550 5551 - 5600 5601 - 5650 5651 - 5700 5701 - 5750 5751 - 5800 5801 - 5850 5851 - 5900 5901 - 5950 5951 - 6000 6001 - 6050 6051 - 6100 6101 - 6150 6151 - 6200 6201 - 6250 6251 - 6300 6301 - 6350 6351 - 6400 6401 - 6450 6451 - 6500 6501 - 6550 6551 - 6600 6601 - 6650 6651 - 6700 6701 - 6750 6751 - 6800 6801 - 6850 6851 - 6900 6901 - 6950 6951 - 7000 7001 - 7050 7051 - 7100 7101 - 7150 7151 - 7200 7201 - 7250 7251 - 7300 7301 - 7350 7351 - 7400 7401 - 7450 7451 - 7500 7501 - 7550 7551 - 7600 7601 - 7650 7651 - 7700 7701 - 7750 7751 - 7800 7801 - 7850 7851 - 7900 7901 - 7950 7951 - 8000 8001 - 8050 8051 - 8100 8101 - 8150 8151 - 8200 8201 - 8250 8251 - 8300 8301 - 8350 8351 - 8400 8401 - 8450 8451 - 8500 8501 - 8550 8551 - 8600 8601 - 8650 8651 - 8700 8701 - 8750 8751 - 8800 8801 - 8850 8851 - 8900 8901 - 8950 8951 - 9000 9001 - 9050 9051 - 9100 9101 - 9150 9151 - 9200 9201 - 9250 9251 - 9300 9301 - 9350 9351 - 9400 9401 - 9450 9451 - 9500 9501 - 9550 9551 - 9600 9601 - 9650 9651 - 9700 9701 - 9750 9751 - 9800 9801 - 9850 9851 - 9900 9901 - 9950 9951 - 10000 10001 - 10050 10051 - 10100 10101 - 10150 10151 - 10200 10201 - 10250 10251 - 10300 10301 - 10350 10351 - 10400 10401 - 10450 10451 - 10500 10501 - 10550 10551 - 10600 10601 - 10642 >

Back to Top



Wait! View more news stories in our News Archive.




Translate


MuggleNet is an unofficial Harry Potter fan site. Please email us if you have any questions or concerns. MuggleNet's original layouts were designed and created by Navy. All subsequent layouts by Dylan Spartz.

© 1999-2009 MuggleNet.com. All rights reserved.

Privacy Policy | COPPA Policy | Feedback | Credits
Random Addresses

1,077 muggles currently online







Poll
Is Dumbledore right that Hogwarts sorts its students into Houses too soon - while the kids are too young?

Updates
Today's Updates
· Updated Crazy Caption Contest [November 15]
Recent Updates
· Updated the Half-Blood Prince DVD info page [November 10]
· Updated Crazy Caption Contest [November 8]
· Updated Crazy Caption Contest [November 1]
Mail

Quotes
Enough — effing — owls...

Vernon Dursley
Order of the Phoenix, Chapter 2, Page 32

See Another Quote
Big News
(10/01) - Happy 10th Birthday, MuggleNet!
(9/30) - HBP breaks $300 million mark in US
(9/25) - JK Rowling is now a Twitter user!
(9/17) - SS and COS Ultimate Editions arriving December 8th too
(9/17) - HBP DVD to hit U.S. stores on December 8
(9/15) - Wizarding World to open Spring 2010, rides confirmed
Release Dates
The Exhibition,
Boston opening:

October 25th, 2009
Half-Blood Prince DVD:
December 8th, 2009
Wizarding World:
Spring 2010
Deathly Hallows, Pt 1:
November 19th, 2010
Deathly Hallows, Pt 2:
July 15th, 2011

Advertisement