Your Deathly Hallows reactions
Your Deathly Hallows reactions Post your thoughts on Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows in the comments of this post, so we can try to keep the discussion more relevant in other news posts!

Go - spill!
Posted by Emerson on Jul 23rd | 10625 Comments
Visitor Comments
Posted by fgweezy Jul 23rd 2007

I loved the book, although now my liscence plate needs to have RIP over the "F" for fred............ Was Umbridge so evil because she was wearing the Slytherin locket/horcrux????


Posted by MsGranger Jul 23rd 2007

MetRupertGrint ---- you guys werent the only ripped off ones. Here in Australia it was ment to be abou 700 pages but it ended up being 659, i got soooooo pissed off!!!! But someone said before, thatt they sobbed during dobby's death, I CRIED LIKE NO TOMORROW. An also at one point i thought Ron or Hermione would die anytime soon, especially when Bellatrix was doing the cruciatous curse on Hermione. OMG I HAVE NVER CRIED SOOOOOOOO MUCH IN MY LIFE!!!


Posted by Rach Jul 23rd 2007

I really love this book. It is my favorite. The batle seen was simply amazing. No other word for it. When Harry was walking to his death it about killed me, I was crying like a baby. I am soo glad I never read any spoilers, because then I could never have had such emotion from it.


Posted by harryordraco Jul 23rd 2007

****SPOILERS*********** Okay what happened to us finding out about what Dudley saw when the Dementors attacked him in OOTP? What happened to the non-magical folk using magic? So many questions! And Fred! WHY FRED? and Lupin and Tonks- Teddy is just like Harry! Orphaned. All the maurders finally dead! So sad!! I was overall happy with the book, Ron and Hermione FINALLY getting togther (before the epilouge obviously ;)Harry and Ginny getting to be together. Harry NOT dying was such a relief! I almost couldn't read the dern thing because I couldn't STAND to think that Harry/Ron/Hermione might not make it! And the Epilouge was sooo cute and sad becase it was their kids and that just made it all final that this was the last book. THREE CHEERS TO JO! Everyone around the world be as passionate about something in life like we are with our Harry Potter!! LONG LIVE HP!


Posted by malans Jul 23rd 2007

complete diappointment. poorly written, poorly plotted, wasn't at all emotionally moving, so many plotholes, so many easy copouts ("accio books on horcruxes", anyone??), inconsistancies, implausibilities, and characters acting or saying things out of character. it read like a bad fanfiction. and wtf is up with the epilogue? she'd been hiding THAT for 15+ years? lamest. ever. i love the harry potter world so much and it pains me that she ended harry's story on such a lame note. well, the joke's on us, JK. i hope you're happy, laughing at us, while sitting on your arse in your castle with the billions you've cheated out of people around the world. i guess i can always look forward to the AS/S fanfics...


Posted by Weasley_Freckles Jul 23rd 2007

OMG I predicted the whole Snape/Dumbledore thing and got it right!!! And don't be disappointed with the epilogue... it was brilliant!!!


Posted by ski_weasleylove23 Jul 23rd 2007

Can anyone answer about who does magic later in life?? i think most of us are wondering about that.


Posted by bono6234 Jul 23rd 2007

I personally loved the book, every character throughout the series seemed to be wrapped up. My favorite part of the book was when Harry returned to Hogwarts, i got goosebumps when i read that. The only real complaint i have was that the book was dated, i like to think that when im reading the stories that they are happening as i read. I dont like thinking that these events took place already. I just didnt see it as necessary and the 1981 didnt need to be included on the Potter's grave stones.


Posted by harrypottre Jul 23rd 2007

i am i must admit a little disappointed. it was an excellent book and maybe my favorite of the serious...but there was alot of unanswered stuff....also i was very intrigued by ginny and harrys relationship and i thought that rowling said ginny would play a big role in the fall of voldemort and she would display great power...well you dont really see anything from her...and the end kind of excludes her as well. mad-eye isnt with harry after the resurection stone and tonks either...it almost seemed a little rushed. i think she could have extended the end a little longer to go into more detail....half the book goes without 1 horcrux being destroyed...why cant we have a little more detail on the biggest climax of the whole series. the final battle..all in all it was entertaining and greatly satisfying..except for that end...epilogue was fun to read. but could have been better...a little confusing at first too. what about luna and all the other people you like....it felt like she left me hanging. but loved it


Posted by Lunazen Jul 23rd 2007

I think that this was the best book by far. I loved the pace of it. I admit I had expected that Harry and friends would delve right into the horcrux hunt with a purpose.. but the way JK handled it was so much more realistic. Of course 17 year olds would not really know where to look or how to begin. The way she clued them in was brilliant. I also liked the epilogue. I've seen many reviews claiming it was cheesy. I thought it was touching and I wonder this: was this the last chapter that she had written long ago? If that's the case, it would make sense that it had a bit of a different tone that the last few books. It was like going back in JK's mind a decade ago :) The emotion, the secrets revealed, the battle...everything was just amazing! Truly an awesome conclusion to the series.


Posted by IrishJay101 Jul 23rd 2007

SPOILER FREE the book was fabulous, it was truely a spectacular end to the series. with so many plot twists, secrets revealed, multiple deaths, and jaw dropping moments, this book is by far the best of the series, at least in my opinion. now as a caution i wouldnt let anyone under 12 read it, for there is violence, there is some hot moments between the charecters, i mean not really bad but enough for some uncomfortable questions ;) and the deaths are a little brutal, and a lil torture and go along way with a child who has yet to understand the principle. but on a scare from 1-10 i rate it a 20. so i implore you enjoy this wonderful masterpiece, and i would like to personally thank J.K.Rowling for this gift that she has given the world.


Posted by pixeegirl Jul 23rd 2007

SOMEONE PLEASE ANSWER ME THIS: Who developed magic late in life? What scene is taking place in the US cover? Because I can't tell.


Posted by polkadot8291 Jul 23rd 2007

I thought that it would have been much more fitting had Teddy Lupin lost his entire family to Voldemort as well. Then Harry could have mirrored his relationship with Sirius as Godfather/Godchild, and it would have brought the tragedy in full circle, but also almost corrected the cycle. Ginny and Harry's marriage was foreseen, but it would have been deeper i think had they taken Teddy in as a surrogate child. The whole "Albus Severus" thing was really lame.... in my mind i was just hearing "wah wahhhh" Also, it was cheesy how all the new children were named after already made characters and that made it confusing. For example, they said that Albus Severus had "Lily's Eyes" speaking of Harry's mother of course, but he also had another daughter who's name was Lily also.... I thought it was lame.


Posted by ginerva_weasley Jul 23rd 2007

I absolutely bawled while reading! Hedwig, Mad-Eye, Fred, Lupin, Tonks, Colin, and about fifty others! Blood bath! And what happened to those 25 pages??? Even in the little paper we got in the books at Barnes and Noble it said "You've read 3000 some pages, only 784 more!" It was only 759...


Posted by JQsGal Jul 23rd 2007

Not sure if anyone replied to polkadotted, but I'm assuming Teddy lived with his grandmother, Tonks' Mom...


Posted by niniel Jul 23rd 2007

When Harry thought Dumbledore had not cared for him and just planned his death- THAT WAS SO HEARTBREAKING! And even Snape couldnt believe it! That's why he killed Dumbledore with this hatred etched on his face... I realised how LONELY this man has been, not able to tell he was still good, NO ONE TO TRUST!!!! No opportunity to laugh. I respect him now. JO, PLEASE WRITE SEVERUS'S MEMOIRS NAD PUBLISH THEM IN AN APPENDIX TO THE SERIES!


Posted by miss_muggle Jul 23rd 2007

Okay, Mugglenet replaced "B-I-TCH" with girl. Not fair, JK Rowling says it :( Also, Tonks and Lupin's deaths were not unnecessary...they made a parallel since Harry was named the godfather, to Harry's parents' deaths with Sirius as the godfather. But the deaths were very sudden and Harry didn't seem all too emotional about them...


Posted by madmuggle66 Jul 23rd 2007

I absolutely LOVED it. I think its the best in the series...but there are so many unanswered questions. Its frusating! And why did Fred have to die? RIP Fred, Lupin, Tonks, and Dobby! JKR really could have answered a lot of questions in the epilogue...but she didnt. now we will probably never know. :( I loved it all the same...but its awful to to know that this is the final book. I would have liked to know more about Teddy. And what happens in the year atfer Harry defeats Voldy. I didnt catch who supposedly got magic late in life......Overall, it was a fantastic book, yet somewhat maddening.


Posted by Opaque Jul 23rd 2007

Overall, I liked it, but there were some things I wished had been different. While I was reading, I kept having the feeling that I was reading a first draft; there were a lot of imbalances and a few things she left out. Personally, I think she should have taken the extra year to write it, but that's just me. And the best line? "He spat at you."


Posted by PotterLove06 Jul 23rd 2007

It is my third favorite book in the series after PoA and GoF. I thought it was an amazing book. The concept of the Deathly Hallows, the importance of the wand choosing the wizard, the snitch (I open at the close), the horrible effect of the locket Horcrux on Ron, the Elder wand, everything was incredible. The only big thing I was disappointed with was the epilogue. I thought it was just too happily ever after and I thought Jo could have done better, but I can deal with it. Of course I'm so glad they all lived to have children and were very happy, but to me I wanted the book to kinda end on a more serious note. But, whatever. I cried my heart out when Hedwig and Dobby died. and when Fred died, I shut the book andcried for five minutes before continuing to read. FRED I LOVE YOU! Amazing, fantastic book. Thank you Jo.


Posted by Tengent Jul 23rd 2007

I really liked it, I may have even liked it mroe that POA! I really sound dumb when I say this.. but where is Harry at on the cover? I don't remember an arena like place on the cover... My favorite part probobly is the beginning of the book, when everyone becomes Harry and they fly ... I've can't wait to see that part in the movie.


Posted by ULfan2890 Jul 23rd 2007

best book of the series by far the plot was awesome and the way she tied in the deathly hallows and the horcruxes was spectacular epilogue was kinda cheesy but overall probably the best book ive ever read


Posted by viki_hp_nerd Jul 23rd 2007

Excellent book! I loved it! I thoguht it was unnecessary to kill off Fred at the end of the book. How come? Grrr. He's my favorite character and I think he should get more mentions in MuggleCast or something!


Posted by papercranefolder Jul 23rd 2007

"Holey" cow, I loved the book. I agree with what people have been saying about the epilouge... it doesn't really tell much. It is pretty vague in my opinion, to book still left me asking questions.


Posted by Ionut Jul 23rd 2007

DH was the best book in the series by far :D I loved every word of it ... heck .... HARRY HUMILIATED VOLDEMORT !!!!!


Posted by mhunt300 Jul 23rd 2007

It was amazing, so many things happening at once plus the speed I read it at just made everything a whirlwind of action and emotion. The ending and the epilogue was perfect, though maybe more info about what happened to everyone was needed. But all in all, once I finished reading this final book my heart sank, I realized this was the last one ever released. But I am happy everything worked out like it should have, and of course there is plenty of room for some fanfiction! :D


Posted by harryfisto Jul 23rd 2007

im lucky i was 16 in line and only got 1 death spoiled it was awesome i even got onstage for an event the great snape debate my side won i even dressed up took a few breaks but finished first day love mugglecast see yah


Posted by babyykakess11 Jul 23rd 2007

best book of the series! a few unanswered questions. epilouge kinda disapointing :[ but the battle at hogwarts made up for everything! :]]


Posted by kaylaweasley Jul 23rd 2007

good book :] loved how everything just fell together in the end! and ron and hermiones kiss was cute :], but the ending really disappointed me! i wanted to know everyones feelings after the war, and how like mrs weasley dealt with freds death and what happened to luna! and just a bunch of every stuff. i think the epiloge could have been way longer. &i still wanted to know about the veil! that wasnt really cleared up for me :/


Posted by sunshineruby Jul 23rd 2007

I can't believe Fred died :( He was the one person I didn't want to die.


Posted by Pottrluvir1025 Jul 23rd 2007

HELLO????? Whatever happened with the veil or the Department of Mysteries???? Jo put such a focus on them in OOTP!!!!! Plus, Jo promised us loads of things that she never even explained, like what Dudley saw when he was with the Dementors or what James and Lily did to "thrice defy Voldemort." Overall it was an excellent book, but the epilogue could've been a lot better and there were MANY loose ends.


Posted by silverdoe7 Jul 23rd 2007

it was wicked awesome. i loved every minute of it. there were a lot of unanswered questions that i thought would be answered like about the veil? and i thought there would be more about the significance of lily's eyes and petunia.


Posted by BoFlo Jul 23rd 2007

Cried and cried and cried when Dumbledore said Harry was a Horcrux. As soon as I read that line, my insides went cold with shock. Read it again and it hit me like a ton of bricks. Burst into tears and did not stop crying until Harry was with Dumbledore at King's Cross. I had to put down the book several times to calm myself down so I could actually read. I was always one of those people who scoffed at the "Harry is a horcrux" theory and could not believe it was true. I was overwhelmed with happiness, though, when he came back to life. Had trouble believing it at first since I didn't want to be crushed again if he DID end up dying, but it was all ok. Epilouge was great, a little more closure would've been nice, but Jo provided enough for me to be satisfied. RIP Lupin/Tonks/Dobby/Hedwig/ Mad-Eye/Fred(WTF)/even Snape


Posted by lumina_lights Jul 23rd 2007

Wow. I feel like a part of my life is missing now that it's over. However, I like how everybody was right. Harry died, but he lived. Snape was bad, but he was good. I just sat and cried at the end because of how much i was going to miss it. But man, did Harry go out with a bang!!!


Posted by wiley1617 Jul 23rd 2007

Wow, the comment box is filling up fast! Anyway, I loved it! Though I was really disapointed with the epiloge. What happened to George! I was a big enough blow to the heart when she killed Fred, but when she diddn't even elaborate on george, well i was throurally (sp?) disapionted! but all in all i thought the book started out great and was an overall excellent book! I also love the fact the she made the whole "will harry live" debate so that every one was right. ( harry lived but he still had to die to kill voldemort) BRILLANT J.K. !!! (a little farfeatched but) BRILLANT!!!!!!


Posted by scorpionqueen74 Jul 23rd 2007

Amazing, incredible, emotional and downright fantastic!! I only with the adjectives came as easily to me as they do to JKR. I think I used at least a half a box of kleenex while reading. Dobby dying was soooo sad! I did not expect that at all.


Posted by Freds_Muse Jul 23rd 2007

No one has commented on Kreacher! How great was that! I love how he came out with the House Elves at the end, crying 'For Regulus!' So great.


Posted by PeaceLoveMalfoy Jul 23rd 2007

omg! am i the only one who went through a withdrawl and was extremely speechless? seriously at the end from fred on i couldn't stop crying... i can't believe it, ending the series is like losing a friend... ~Tricia


Posted by x_kitty_x Jul 23rd 2007

I just want to say phah to all those people in the comments before the book came out just putting 'harry is going to die' I mean JK would never of done it. I mean properly cause Harry did kinda die but not. Any way I loved the book I never wanted it to end. I know JK will probally not do aother Harry book but shall we all just beg anyway what do you think? PLEASE JO WE BEG YOU!


Posted by hpiml34 Jul 23rd 2007

I though that overall, this was the best book of the series. I read it almost three times all the way through just on Saturday! I especially loved the battle at Hogwarts and Snape's and Dumbledore's stories, but I thought that the epilogue left much to be desired. I also didn't like how J.K. Rowling didn't answer several of the questions that she said she would. For instance, we never found the Potter's occupations or the character that did magic late in life.


Posted by Rose4Harry Jul 23rd 2007

P.S. it's funny, MuggleNet, that you changed Bitc you know what to girl! sorry I wrote that, it's just such a Cool part in the book! You rule, MuggleNet.Thanks


Posted by captainjack15 Jul 23rd 2007

the book was fantastic, but the epilogue sounded like a fanfic, i thought. but all in all it was definitely one of the better books :]


Posted by Hermione_Granger Jul 23rd 2007

Okay i LOVED the book totally loved it.. and it hit me hard when I got to the Epilogue there I realized it was the end of Harry Potter Books! and started crying!! :( Anyways the epilogue i think could have been more detailed about Harry + Ginny she could have told a little bit more of what happened (altough deep down inside we knoe) and also the Ron + Hermione but LOVED the book was amazing altough I have a Question... If it was 19 yrs latter.. HOW come does Teddy end's up in The Hogwarts Express??? He's 19 yrs old... (weird) there were other incoincistencies but i guess it's nothing that we cannot guess.. (i guess)


Posted by colorfulcrocs Jul 23rd 2007

DEATHLY HALLOWS WAS INCREDIBLE!!! I laughed, I cried... I lost a significant amount of sleep... and now I'm horribly sad, because there won't be another one! I think the worst part was when Dobby died. I was heartbroken! All in all, I'm elated to finally know what happened.


Posted by Phoenixflight14 Jul 23rd 2007

Although I believe it is an excellent novel over all. I thought parts of it were slow and that it contained too much information.


Posted by snowboard453 Jul 23rd 2007

I'm really sad now. Harry Potter has been with me since I was 6. My mom read it to me before it was very popular. I thought the book was amazing. I cried when Fred died. Him and George were my favorite characters. My favorite part was when Snapes name was redeemed and how Harry said that his son was named after two headmasters and one of them was the bravest person he knew and he was talking about Snape. AMAZING!!!!!!!!


Posted by Joanna_ Jul 23rd 2007

I loved it! Poor Hedwig though! And I liked that the sword revealed itself to Neville, shows the link with the prophecy and how easily Neville could have had Harry's fate. It is enchanted to reveal itself to a true Gryffindor, so the fact that Griphook had it is irrelevant. I could write for ages about this book! Well done J.K. Rowling for giving the series a fitting end! xx


Posted by tbequ Jul 23rd 2007

first off i thought it was the best book in the series and secondly if teddy tonks was born during the war and the epilogue took place nineteen years later, then wouldn't he be nineteen years old and be done with Hogwarts. Why was he on the Hogwarts Express? Wasn't the book supposed to be 784 pages??


Posted by sarahc4104 Jul 23rd 2007

Very disappointing. The book answered very few of the questions that the author promised to tie up in this book. The plot was inconsistent and had some huge holes. The epilogue was also amazingly disappointing. Did anyone notice Lupin and Tonk's son would have been 19 at the end, and therefore too old to still be at Hogwarts? Not my favorite book by any means, it was obviously rushed and her editors must have been sleeping..


Posted by Weasleysourking Jul 23rd 2007

Absolutely amazing! I bought the book at midnight at Borders, and read the whole thing! I couldn't put it down. I loved the twists and turns. And that's what the Deathly Hallows were!? Who new? I cried my eyes out! My favorite book without a doubt. Loved it. Anyone else feel an odd sense of loss? I do. =(.


< 1 - 50 51 - 100 101 - 150 151 - 200 201 - 250 251 - 300 301 - 350 351 - 400 401 - 450 451 - 500 501 - 550 551 - 600 601 - 650 651 - 700 701 - 750 751 - 800 801 - 850 851 - 900 901 - 950 951 - 1000 1001 - 1050 1051 - 1100 1101 - 1150 1151 - 1200 1201 - 1250 1251 - 1300 1301 - 1350 1351 - 1400 1401 - 1450 1451 - 1500 1501 - 1550 1551 - 1600 1601 - 1650 1651 - 1700 1701 - 1750 1751 - 1800 1801 - 1850 1851 - 1900 1901 - 1950 1951 - 2000 2001 - 2050 2051 - 2100 2101 - 2150 2151 - 2200 2201 - 2250 2251 - 2300 2301 - 2350 2351 - 2400 2401 - 2450 2451 - 2500 2501 - 2550 2551 - 2600 2601 - 2650 2651 - 2700 2701 - 2750 2751 - 2800 2801 - 2850 2851 - 2900 2901 - 2950 2951 - 3000 3001 - 3050 3051 - 3100 3101 - 3150 3151 - 3200 3201 - 3250 3251 - 3300 3301 - 3350 3351 - 3400 3401 - 3450 3451 - 3500 3501 - 3550 3551 - 3600 3601 - 3650 3651 - 3700 3701 - 3750 3751 - 3800 3801 - 3850 3851 - 3900 3901 - 3950 3951 - 4000 4001 - 4050 4051 - 4100 4101 - 4150 4151 - 4200 4201 - 4250 4251 - 4300 4301 - 4350 4351 - 4400 4401 - 4450 4451 - 4500 4501 - 4550 4551 - 4600 4601 - 4650 4651 - 4700 4701 - 4750 4751 - 4800 4801 - 4850 4851 - 4900 4901 - 4950 4951 - 5000 5001 - 5050 5051 - 5100 5101 - 5150 5151 - 5200 5201 - 5250 5251 - 5300 5301 - 5350 5351 - 5400 5401 - 5450 5451 - 5500 5501 - 5550 5551 - 5600 5601 - 5650 5651 - 5700 5701 - 5750 5751 - 5800 5801 - 5850 5851 - 5900 5901 - 5950 5951 - 6000 6001 - 6050 6051 - 6100 6101 - 6150 6151 - 6200 6201 - 6250 6251 - 6300 6301 - 6350 6351 - 6400 6401 - 6450 6451 - 6500 6501 - 6550 6551 - 6600 6601 - 6650 6651 - 6700 6701 - 6750 6751 - 6800 6801 - 6850 6851 - 6900 6901 - 6950 6951 - 7000 7001 - 7050 7051 - 7100 7101 - 7150 7151 - 7200 7201 - 7250 7251 - 7300 7301 - 7350 7351 - 7400 7401 - 7450 7451 - 7500 7501 - 7550 7551 - 7600 7601 - 7650 7651 - 7700 7701 - 7750 7751 - 7800 7801 - 7850 7851 - 7900 7901 - 7950 7951 - 8000 8001 - 8050 8051 - 8100 8101 - 8150 8151 - 8200 8201 - 8250 8251 - 8300 8301 - 8350 8351 - 8400 8401 - 8450 8451 - 8500 8501 - 8550 8551 - 8600 8601 - 8650 8651 - 8700 8701 - 8750 8751 - 8800 8801 - 8850 8851 - 8900 8901 - 8950 8951 - 9000 9001 - 9050 9051 - 9100 9101 - 9150 9151 - 9200 9201 - 9250 9251 - 9300 9301 - 9350 9351 - 9400 9401 - 9450 9451 - 9500 9501 - 9550 9551 - 9600 9601 - 9650 9651 - 9700 9701 - 9750 9751 - 9800 9801 - 9850 9851 - 9900 9901 - 9950 9951 - 10000 10001 - 10050 10051 - 10100 10101 - 10150 10151 - 10200 10201 - 10250 10251 - 10300 10301 - 10350 10351 - 10400 10401 - 10450 10451 - 10500 10501 - 10550 10551 - 10600 10601 - 10642 >

Back to Top



Wait! View more news stories in our News Archive.




Translate


MuggleNet is an unofficial Harry Potter fan site. Please email us if you have any questions or concerns. MuggleNet's original layouts were designed and created by Navy. All subsequent layouts by Dylan Spartz.

© 1999-2009 MuggleNet.com. All rights reserved.

Privacy Policy | COPPA Policy | Feedback | Credits
Random Addresses

1,047 muggles currently online







Poll
Is Dumbledore right that Hogwarts sorts its students into Houses too soon - while the kids are too young?

Updates
Today's Updates
· Updated Crazy Caption Contest [November 15]
Recent Updates
· Updated the Half-Blood Prince DVD info page [November 10]
· Updated Crazy Caption Contest [November 8]
· Updated Crazy Caption Contest [November 1]
Mail

Quotes
I wouldn't go out with you if it was a choice between you and the giant squid.

Lily Potter
Order of the Phoenix

See Another Quote
Big News
(10/01) - Happy 10th Birthday, MuggleNet!
(9/30) - HBP breaks $300 million mark in US
(9/25) - JK Rowling is now a Twitter user!
(9/17) - SS and COS Ultimate Editions arriving December 8th too
(9/17) - HBP DVD to hit U.S. stores on December 8
(9/15) - Wizarding World to open Spring 2010, rides confirmed
Release Dates
The Exhibition,
Boston opening:

October 25th, 2009
Half-Blood Prince DVD:
December 8th, 2009
Wizarding World:
Spring 2010
Deathly Hallows, Pt 1:
November 19th, 2010
Deathly Hallows, Pt 2:
July 15th, 2011

Advertisement