MuggleNet's Decade in Review | MuggleNet's April Fools Day 2008
Deathly Hallows Info | MN/TLC Interview with J.K. Rowling
No Weasley is our King storyline in OOTP
Bad news for those who are looking forward to a good grudge match in the Order of the Phoenix film next summer! We've been informed that there is no storyline in the movie surrounding Ron's Quidditch hardships, nor has there been any filming on broomsticks done by Rupert. We're led to believe that this means there will be no Quidditch in the fifth film at all. We hope to learn more soon!
Posted by Andrew on Aug 26th |
741 Comments


Visitor Comments












I suppose I'm not too surprised, but I would have loved part of the Quidditch storyline in the film. It wouldn't give us the same Ron that we had in the books, but I realized with a two and a half hour movie of an 870 page book, there are going to be some MAJOR cuts and changes. :(
THIS SUCKS SO BAD.
That's bull spit! They always get rid of these awesome sub plots
-*small part of me dies*-
ARE YOU KIDDING ME?! harry potter IS quidditch, COME ON!!!!!!!
I feel like they always leave out quidditch! And if they do put it in it's all drama between malfoy and harry which takes away from the game. It stunk in the 3rd movie because the 3rd book has the best quidditch
awww :( does that mean no hr/r kiss?? oh well, i bet they will find another way to put it in somewhere... (after all, even though im against h/hr, in GOF she kissed harry after the 2nd task even though they cut out her kissing him at the end of the book) sooo..... i think they will still find a way to put it in somehow.
Surely we've known about this for a while. After all, it's just about the only thing that we've heard nothing about in the Ootp production. We know about the Dursleys, the Dementor scene, Grawp, the Centaurs, the DA, Harry and Cho kiss, Ministry, Inquisitorial Squad, Trelawny class, Snapes Worst Memory and much more but no mention of Quidditch. Also, I'm sure we had the question 'is there going to be Quidditch' answered by someone. If anything needed to be cut out it was Quidditch. Well, I would have cut Grawp but he MUST end up being important.
That's odd, and absolutely disapointing but honestly, every movie changes something - more or less, that we want in/a certain way. We've just got to accept the changes and hope for the best. That's why the books are better, and always have been. :)
OMG!!!!!! I'm crying right now! That is such a main part!!!! MY HOPE HAS DIED NOW FOR THE 5th MOVIE!!!! *sobs*
*sings softly* Ron won't have a chance, Ron won't have a chance, To hear the others sing his song, Weasley is our King.
WHAT!!!! That is such a bad idea to not have. I was really looking forward to those scences, because I thought the whole Weasley is Our King storyline was awesome, and the song was [[mean but]] funny. Rawr...what are they going to cut next?
By the way, there's a chance they will include some of Ron's Quidditch story in the HBP movie. Quidditch will certainly be back in that movie, there's just no room for it in Ootp.
awww, this is just like how the producers didn't include SPEW in the last film.
Hmm...OotP is my least favorite book (SO. MUCH. ANGST), so for once (and I mean that sincerely), I don't really care what they cut out, just so long as it's not Umbridge. She was horrible...in a good, what-a-great-writer-JK-is sort of way, because she was a very well made character.
WHAT??? NO WEASLEY IS OUR KING? well i guess that's fine, but wouldn't ruin the plot somewhat? i mean, how with Harry and the Weasley twins get banned from Quidditch? ~rvengurl89
I too am disappointed. No Luna's Lion Hat. No Ron-Hermione peck on the cheek. No cool song. I don't personally care about Quidditch and it is sorta boring but I love all the things relating to it in OotP. How are they going to bring it back up for Movie 6?! (Oh yeah viewers, Ron is the keeper now for no apparent reason!) riddle me that. And if its not in HBP then fans can say goodbye to Luna's commentating and the Felix Felicis scene which I think says a lot about Ron. PS: Rupert is an awesome actor and should, nay deserves a great storyline and not have all his best scenes cut out or best lines given to Emma.
I really hope this news is not true -- but if it is, I hope WB would re-think this and decide to shoot even just a short scene showing Ron's winning moment as Harry and Hermione comes out of their forest interlude with Grawp -- I think that doesn't take much -- just a few seconds -- just the crowd singing and Ron descending to the ground to the Gryffindor team's joyous celebration! Okay, seriously, I should be scriptwriting OotP -- I'm sure a lot of fans will be happier with what I can come up with :D Actually, I'm just trying to cheer myself up :/ its hard when you really feel like crying :(
You know, I read somewhere once that Harry, Ron and Hermione went to find Grawp and now I'm wondering if that rumour was true at all.
Im tired of WB cutting out All the subplsots they are the most important thngs in the books. This will be as Crapp* as the 4th movie. I gues if the dont butcher it much more it might be OK.
Wow... It looks like OotP is dead in the minds of a few thousand fans, and we've still got 320 freaking days until it's out. (It's not dead to me yet; it's just a bit... diseased.)
Nooooo, dammit i wuz loking forward to dat dammit. they always do this dammit. cuttin out stuff . ahhh " now im really depressed" lol sike laterz !!!!!WHY??!!!
There was a Mugglenet editorial last year that predicted that we would never see Quidditch again...and they were right! If its not about HARRY, its not in the movie.
Lord of the Rings i like.... 1000 pages and it was nearly a 13 hour long movie! OOTP is 870 and it's going to be like, 3 hours at best...OBVIOUSLY some STUFF MUST BE CUT! You all b*tch now, but come next summer you'll be talking about how it's the best movie so far and every better than goblet! Don't we remember the past!?
BBBBBOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO. What the hell is going on. All i really wanted was to hear was the roaring chant of "Weasley is Our King!". Screw this bloody writer and same goes to David Yates!!!
what??? nooo. but thats a big part of rons charcter development and does that mean that they wont announce in the sixth movie that harry was made quidditch captain because thats even worse. how can they put it into the sixth movie if they dont put it in the fifth. that means that theres not going to be any quittich in the sixth movie too. boooo!!!!!
Gah! -deep breath , exhale- Alright, I'm disapointed but I'd rather have Quidditch cut out than some of my favourite scenes. But I was looking foreword to the life-long Quidditch Ban. It adds to Harry's angst. -deep sigh- I just hope they can find another way to take away their brooms.
What?That's messed up!Man,I loved that part of the book
OMG i am soooooooooooooo mad im not going to even see the movie(haha jk) umm but im really p-oed.............HOW CAN THEY DO THIS TO MEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
watching the movies has always been a somewhat painful experience, flinching everytime things are different than the books. I feel bad for Rupert who was looking forward to Quiddich.
What?! No!! Ron's my favorite. Poor Ron.
Uhh! Bugger! This is just going downhill far too fast ...
It so NOT nice! I have been WAITING for this scene and it is CUT! I also really want to hear the song! I'm sure that many people are REALLY ANNOYED NOW!
Disappointed so far.. Bah, let's see.
*GASP* WHY??? oops... i think i just woke up my sister. but still... I know it isn't absolutely relevant to the plot but... thats one of rons best moments. and one of the best moments in the book... but wait... if there is no quidditch, then harry doesnt beat up malfoy and get kicked off the team... or are they gonna write that in somewhere else? *sigh* but seeing as the past two movies turned out... i wouldn't be surprised if this was true.
Ugh...why do they have to change everything? I bet they're going to "forget" that Tonks is a metamorphamangus too. I like the Quidditch mathes though :(
So much for any Ron character development whatsoever....
Im sad but thats still understandable. oh well. I guess umbridge will cancel quiditch at the start of the term for some reason.
That honestly isn't right. They have already cut down the movies enough, why are they removing one of the funniest little story lines in the book! that's just outrageous.
THIS SUCKS!!!!!!!! THERE HAS TO BE QUIDDITCH, AND RON HAS TO PLAY QUIDDITCH!!!!!!! I HOPE THAT THEY'RE JUST PLAYING A TRICK ON US WHEN THEY SAY THAT THERE'S NOT GOING TO BE ANY QUIDDITCH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1
BRING BACK QUIDDITCH!!!! GRRR!!!!
I really wanted to hear them sing the song. Oh well... guess ot everyone wuld love a 10 hour movie. sigh
This is getting ridicukous...first no Winky in GOF and now this! THis is really disappointing me how...bad...the movies are getting. What a shame...
i just gasped out loud. i ammm soooo upset. i really dont' know what to think about right now. another movie without any quidditch and no weasley king. i am extremley upset right now.
Two words: that sucks.
not cool...not cool at all :(
Wow, and they are probably going to replace that storyline with a scene like the freaking long dragon/harry scene in GoF or the hyppogriff/harry scene in PoA. Personally, I think that Ron's character development, as well as other main characters', are more important than random scenes with harry and random magical creatures or even a random choir singing a song not even in the book. I think the film-makers will run into a lot of trouble with the sixth, and even seventh movie if none of their characters, besides Harry of course, are developed.
That. Sux.
ok, i agree with jess10. and really what are they going to take out next? Harry? A HP film with out quidditch is like strawberry shortcake without the strawberries! Its just not right! And it's, like, super important too, the quidditch, I mean, but the strawberries are good too..... But honestly! I was mad when WB didn't let me try out for a part in the movie cuz I wasn't european, but now I don't want to be in the movie anymore if they're just going to ruin it with crap like this!
Well, I guess they had to cut out something, I mean it was the longest book, and if they cut some of GOF, they DEFINITELY had to cut something from OOTP... but quidditch?? dang.. :(
Back to Top